High-quality and surround sound ensures complete immersion in watching: a movie, series, sports broadcast, TV show, etc. Clear sound also allows you to enjoy your music. The speakers built into modern TVs are not capable of providing the proper level of quality. Therefore, users are looking for alternative solutions: sound bars, speaker systems, recreation centers and stereo systems. Which is better to choose?
What is a soundbar
Soundbar is a budget-friendly, simple alternative to home theater. Inside the narrow soundbar are speakers and other components. Active device models are connected directly to a power source (220V), which are equipped with:
- speakers;
- switch;
- decoder;
- sound amplifier.
You can also purchase a passive soundbar. Inside there are exclusively acoustic elements. An external amplifier is connected separately. The speakers are located in accordance with the diagram. Three-piece models include: center, left and right speakers. As for multi-component models, they are additionally equipped with elements that simulate rear speakers. They also reproduce sound special effects.
The Soundbar can be placed on the wall under the TV. An alternative method is installation on a special rack. The headset may also have shelves necessary for installing a subwoofer and amplifier. The soundbar is not suitable for reproducing low frequencies, however, this problem is easily solved by connecting a subwoofer. This will significantly improve the sound quality.
Some soundbar models are sold with a subwoofer, which is included in the basic package of the device. Today you can get a soundbar with a wireless subwoofer. Wireless synchronization of equipment is an extremely practical and convenient solution. All elements of the acoustic system can be located in different places.
Soundbar is the best purchase for installation in a small room. The equipment takes up a minimum of free space and also costs much less than a recreation center.
It should be noted that a sound bar is an additional device necessary to improve sound quality. Quite often, sound panels are installed in the kitchen or bedroom. Some users even prefer to connect the soundbar to the computer instead of regular speakers.
Which is better: home theater or soundbar? For an objective assessment, it is necessary to conduct a comprehensive study of the strengths and weaknesses of this technique.
Pros and cons of both options
No matter how good the technology is, it tends to have both advantages and disadvantages. Let's figure out what they are.
Soundbar
This type of technology is equipped with significant advantages that will be key for many. However, there are also disadvantages:
Advantages
- compactness
- will fix low sound quality
- low cost
Flaws
- selection for TV size
- the sound is not big enough
- lower quality sound
Home cinema
When purchasing this type of device, a person will receive more opportunities and advantages. They are as follows:
Advantages
- has a professional sound
- there are sound effects
- possibility of remote control
- plays audio from any media
Flaws
- requires specialist intervention to configure
- takes up a lot of space and is not portable
- high price
It can be seen that the home theater has disadvantages that are not directly related to the quality of the product. The soundbar is the opposite. It follows from this that when comparing the options, there is only one conclusion - the home theater turns out to be better.
Home theater characteristics
The difference between a home theater and a soundbar is that it is a full-fledged system consisting of several speakers that can provide surround multi-channel sound. All speakers are placed around the perimeter of the room. A properly assembled home theater will provide truly high-quality sound.
DC is a universal complex that can be upgraded by connecting additional components. The arrangement of the speakers is carried out in accordance with a special scheme. The viewing point should be in the center of the room. The user will be able to experience basic and peripheral sounds. The distance between the columns can be changed.
A home theater consists of the following elements:
- media player that provides image transmission;
- speakers – their number varies from 5 to 7 depending on the model;
- subwoofer.
A home theater should be purchased in cases where the square footage of the room allows it. The living room should be very spacious. A small room will cause a lack of surround sound.
Arguments in favor of purchasing:
- superior quality surround sound;
- setting and changing the arrangement of elements depending on the room;
- remote control of sound quality.
Arguments against buying:
- high price;
- not the easiest setup and connection process;
- suitable for owners of spacious rooms.
Rating of the best models
Both types of sound systems have their pros and cons. Soundbars are easy to set up and small in size. They are more suitable for those who want to enhance the sound or get not only acoustics for the TV, but also replace a stereo system.
Home cinema is the choice of people who are not constrained by funds and those who are true connoisseurs of sound. In addition, the home theater is designed for fairly large rooms, for example, in a one-room apartment there is no particular point in installing such a system, because it cannot be used even to 50% of its capabilities.
To help users, below I have listed the best models of both types of devices available on the market, selected based on customer reviews.
Sony BDV-E3100
Home theater 5.1 with a total power of 1000 W. The model is equipped with a disk drive, has a TV tuner and can work with iPOD. The device has a built-in equalizer with 5 preset modes and has a huge number of decoders. The center speaker produces 250 W, front and rear – 125 W, subwoofer – 250 W. Optical audio cables are used for connection, there is an HDMI output for connecting to TV, support for Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, Ethernet, DLNA. The device has a built-in FM radio with 20 radio stations in memory, and is designed to connect external HDDs and keyboards.
Cost – from 17,700 rubles.
LG LHB655
Home theater with 1000 W power and Blu-ray player. There is an output for connecting a microphone, which allows you to use it as a karaoke. Connection: optical audio cables, HDMI, USB output. Wireless interfaces - Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, DLNA. A large number of decoders, built-in radio with the ability to save 50 stations. Users note that the disadvantages of the device are the poor coating of the speakers (they quickly collect dust), short wires, and the inability to mount the speakers on the wall. The model is the best choice for watching movies. True music lovers will not like the model.
Cost – from 22,800 rubles.
Samsung HT-J5550K
The home theater from Samsung received a 5.1 system with a total power of 1000 W. Unlike the previous version, there are more decoders and it has 8 preset equalizer modes. Equipped with a Blu-ray drive. Connects via optical audio cables, there is HDMI, USB, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Ethernet, as well as DLNA support (the ability to connect an audio system to your home network). There is a built-in radio - 15 stations.
Cost – from 26 thousand rubles.
Onkyo HT-S5805
The Onkyo brand comes from Japan and is considered a professional in the field of audio. The company's equipment is not cheap, but it is completely worth the money. There is a receiver designed to connect a 7.1 system, but this configuration offers buyers 5 speakers and a sub. Unlike numerous budget options, the speaker body is made of wood. It is most likely not necessary to explain the advantages of this material over plastic - a tighter connection, which helps to avoid rattling during loud playback. The receiver supports Dolby Atmos technology, which is currently considered the best standard of sound quality. The case has a huge number of connectors for connection; a true connoisseur of acoustic devices can figure them out. To set up the device, a microphone is supplied. It is located in the place where the user will sit and allows you to calibrate the location of the speakers. The total power in version 5.1 is 500 W. At the same time, the sound level is professional, unlike previous models with a power of 1000 W, but at an amateur level. At its price, this is one of the most affordable, but truly high-quality home theaters.
Cost – from 65 thousand rubles.
LG SJ3
Class 2.1 soundbar with 300W power. Active speaker system with built-in amplifier. The soundbar produces 100 W of sound, the remaining 200 W comes from the sub. Has support for DTS, Dolby Digital. The subwoofer connects wirelessly. Connection to TV is provided using an optical audio cable. The speaker can be placed on the wall, it is possible to configure control from the TV remote control, which is quite convenient - you don’t need to use several.
Cost – from 11,100 rubles.
Sharp HT-SB106
Soundbar without a subwoofer with a power of 110 W, frequency – 60 – 20000 Hz. Connects via Bluetooth, has a light weight - 1.3 kg and compact dimensions. Will be an excellent choice for a small room. The case received connectors - full HDMI, 3.5, optical. There is a possibility of placing it on the wall - the necessary fastenings are included in the package.
Cost – from 7 thousand rubles.
JBL Bar 2.1
JBL is known to almost all users for its portable speakers for smartphones. Today the brand is trying its hand at producing acoustics for TVs. The model received a speaker and a subwoofer, which in total can produce 300 W. standard frequency range – from 40 to 20000 Hz. It is quite compact in size and light in weight. There is a wall mount. The sub connects to the speaker via a Bluetooth connection. To synchronize with TV, use an HDMI cable or an optical optical cord. The case has an output for a flash drive, which allows you to listen to music or play videos from it. There is a built-in Dolby Digital decoder. The soundbar is perfect for those who want to enjoy high-quality music playback and want to watch movies in high definition. The kit includes a convenient control panel.
Cost – from 17 thousand rubles.
Sources
- https://zen.yandex.ru/media/id/5dd270694052283fcdc4bc29/5df8d54f6d29c199b0a5388e
- https://hifidesign.ru/reviews/saundbar_domashnie_kinoteatry/
- https://ProSmartTV.ru/tehnologii/saundbar-ili-domashnij-kinoteatr.html
- https://www.wekom.ru/saundbar-ili-domashnij-kinoteatr-chto-sleduet-vybrat/
- https://www.kp.ru/putevoditel/tekhnologii/luchshie-saundbary/
- https://stroy-podskazka.ru/saundbar/ili-domashnij-kinoteatr/
- https://ya-rostislav.ru/tele-audio-video/soundbar/chto-luchshe-domashniy-kinoteatr-ili
Music Center
The name of this device speaks for itself. A music center is an acoustic system capable of playing and recording audio content. Functionality directly depends on the technical characteristics of a particular model. Manufacturers of stereo systems make every effort to ensure that their products are compatible with popular digital formats.
Music centers are divided into subgroups depending on size and design:
- microsystem – compact monoblock;
- minisystem - a medium-sized block;
- media system – installed in nightclubs.
Having finally become convinced of the need to purchase a music center, the user needs to remember the real inconveniences of its use, which will manifest themselves during operation:
- a multifunctional system is very expensive;
- impressive dimensions of the music center, subwoofer and amplifier;
- not the easiest process to connect to a TV.
Of course, there are also advantages, namely:
- reproducing content from outdated media;
- several channels of audio stream playback;
- wide range of different models;
- high quality sound.
Fundamental differences
- Soundbars have compact dimensions and light weight, while home theaters are bulky systems and contain a lot of elements.
- DCs provide high sound quality, but when using a soundbar it will stop only at an acceptable level.
- The soundbar is extremely easy to install and connect, which can be completed in a few minutes. And to connect the DC, the user will need to tinker a lot. Of course, there are wireless models, but their cost is obscenely high.
- Remote control is present on all home theater systems. But soundbars cannot boast of such a result, and only some models have it.
- The cost of soundbars is more than affordable, while DCs cost a decent amount of money.
Which of the presented devices you choose is up to you. But remember that a soundbar is a great option for small rooms, and a home theater for medium-sized and large-sized rooms. Enjoy the shopping!
Subscribe to our Social networks
Acustic systems
Speaker systems can be independent or serve as speakers in a home theater system. Speakers mainly consist of powerful speakers and a subwoofer. Therefore, high-quality reproduction of low frequencies is guaranteed. According to the installation method, they are classified into the following types:
- floor;
- built-in;
- satellite;
- shelf;
- wall-mounted
Based on functionality, they are classified into the following groups:
- central channel;
- operating in different weather conditions;
- landscape;
- rear
Initially, it may seem that acoustic systems are too primitive a type of technology, but this is a big misconception. Using speakers to play media content has a wide range of advantages:
- long service life;
- amplifier power is automatically adjusted in accordance with the parameters of the speakers;
- clear sound.
Owners of acoustic systems note that during operation of the equipment certain shortcomings will be noticeable:
- if the amplifier breaks down, this component will be extremely difficult to replace;
- problems with frequency calibration;
- limited functionality.
What to look for when choosing?
To fully understand the capabilities of both options, it is necessary to study their parameters and functions in more detail. It will become easier to make a decision and be satisfied with your purchase.
Soundbar
It is worth paying attention to the following characteristics:
- Availability of HDMI port.
This is the optimal interface option, in which you can not only get excellent sound, but also control both the TV and the soundbar itself using one remote control. Sometimes you can also find a USB connector, which is a plus: it’s easy to connect a memory device to play audio files; - Bluetooth connection.
It will help if you listen to music from your phone. For people who actively listen to music from their phone player, this function is ideal and will become a significant advantage. - Channel configuration.
There are several variations: 2.0, 2.1, 3.1 and 7.1. For example, 2.0 is the most common stereo system. With the addition of pronounced bass, you get 2.1. And the 7.1 configuration will create surround sound. It’s worth keeping in mind that the higher the number, the more expensive the device. The numbers indicate the number of speakers (the first is the total number of speakers, the second is the number of subwoofers). - Number of Watts.
Responsible for power and sound purity. To evaluate this parameter, it is best to come to the store and listen to different models of the device. But if you order online, you should pay attention to soundbars that have more watts. For an apartment this is usually about 80 W.
Conclusions – which is better to choose?
Which is better: soundbar or home theater? Perhaps you should give preference to a music center or speaker system? Each type of technology has its own strengths and weaknesses that must be taken into account. If we talk specifically about sound quality, the undisputed leader is the home theater, which is noticeably different from a soundbar, speakers and music center:
- Users will be able to arrange all elements of the home theater system in accordance with their needs and taking into account the characteristics of the room. A fine control system will allow you to achieve the highest quality sound.
- The functional components of DCs significantly exceed sound bars in terms of technical characteristics, which ensures a surround sound effect and full immersion in viewing.
- Home theaters support absolutely all modern audio and video formats, which cannot be said, for example, about music centers. They are mostly used for playing music.
- Repairing a home theater system is much easier than repairing speaker systems. Therefore, the service life will be long, and the cost of maintenance will be as favorable as possible.
- Home theater owners will be able to customize the sound and image to suit their needs.
Now you know what to choose in Moscow: soundbar, home theater, speaker system, music center. If you plan to install the equipment in a small room, then it makes more sense to purchase a soundbar. This solution also allows you to save a lot of money.
How to make a choice
Despite the obvious advantages of both types of devices, in any case you have to make a choice and find out what is best for your home or apartment. If your living space is not large and spacious, you want to save space and still enjoy good sound at any convenient time, a convenient and high-quality sound bar will be the best option for you. At the same time, it will be much more pleasant for a long-time music lover and film fan to have an ultra-modern system at home with a large list of interesting options, which can replace going to the cinema and give an unforgettable viewing experience. Choosing a quality device is not at all difficult thanks to the huge selection of equipment in retail and online stores. When choosing, you can also rely on our current ratings of the best soundbars and home theaters.
When choosing a system, it is better to focus on your needs and feelings from sound and other factors. It is also worth considering the features of the room in which you plan to install a home system or sound bar: the sound is always strongly influenced by the acoustic properties of the room, the location of the walls and the location of the speakers. The aesthetic side is also important, since any system must fit well into the interior.
The best premium soundbars
Well, let's finish with options for buyers who are not strapped for cash.
Bose Soundtouch 300
- Type: 2.0
- Power: 75 W
- Price: 56 thousand rubles
The reader will ask a reasonable question: why pay 56 thousand, if there is not even a separate subwoofer and the power of the bar is several times less than that of competitors. However, the Soundtouch 300 is positioned as a premium product, and therefore special emphasis here, in addition to sound quality, is placed on the quality of workmanship - the soundbar made of metal and glass looks simply luxurious in real life, and it also has a number of unique functions. For example, there is an NFC module, which allows you to instantly connect a smartphone or tablet to the acoustics.
And everything is fine with the sound here. The Soundtouch 300 includes a special microphone, which is used to calibrate sound - the system determines the position of the microphone in space and adjusts the propagation of sound waves in the room and taking into account the position of the listener. You can upgrade the SB300 by purchasing rear speakers and a subwoofer from the same manufacturer, the latter is called Bose Acoustimass 300 and costs almost 60 thousand rubles.
LG SK9Y
- Type: 2.1
- Power: 500W
- Price: 56 thousand rubles
LG SK9Y is a soundbar loaded to the brim with the latest technology. Unlike cheaper analogs that can only emulate surround sound, it supports Dolby Atmos technology, which is used in modern cinemas. The system sounds bright and clear, the bass is velvety, and the detail and scene of sound sources will surprise even the most demanding users. There is support for Hi-Res audio 192/24 bits, which is almost never found in this class of audio equipment. The LG SK9Y has no drawbacks, but to unlock its full potential, it would still be a good idea to supplement it with SPL8-S rear speakers.
Sources
- https://Otvet.tv/tehnika/akusticheskaya-sistema/saundbar-domashnij-kinoteatr-muz-tsentr-chto-luchshe.html
- https://tehnopomosh.com/tsifrovaya/domashnij-kinoteatr/kinoteatr-ili-saundbar.html
- https://setafi.com/elektronika/domashnij-kinoteatr/xem-otlichaetsya-saundbar-ot-domashnego-kinoteatra/
- https://stroy-podskazka.ru/saundbar/ili-domashnij-kinoteatr/
- https://ProSmartTV.ru/tehnologii/saundbar-ili-domashnij-kinoteatr.html
- https://tehnika.expert/cifrovaya/domashnij-kinoteatr/ili-saundbar-chto-luchshe.html
- https://geekville.ru/rejtingi/rejting-luchshih-saundbarov-2019-goda-v-raznyh-tsenovyh-kategoriyah/
