Comparative characteristics of inhalers (nebulizers)


Place Name Characteristics in the rating
TOP 10 best OMRON nebulizers
1Omron CompAir NE-C28 PlusThe most powerful nebulizer
2Omron Comp Air NE-C24 KidsBest for baby
3Omron Micro Air NE-U22High efficiency
4Omron CompAir NE-C25The best nasal shower device
5Omron Comp Air NE-C30 EliteThe most compact compressor inhaler
6Omron Comp Air NE-C20 basicBest price
7Omron DuoBaby NE-C301The best device with masks for children and adults
8Omron Comp Air NE-C300Possibility to select a mode
9Omron CompAir NE-C21 basicConvenient design. Low noise level
10Omron Comp Air NE-C24Equipped with special technology

Buy an Omron inhaler and you can’t go wrong. Comparison of C24 and C28.

Today, the variety of nebulizers is very large. Everyone chooses according to their needs and the price that suits them. Among the most popular nebulizers among buyers are Omron CompAir NE-C24-RU and Omron CompAir NE-C28-E

Omron C24 inhaler Omron C28 inhaler

To make the right choice, we suggest that you read this article, which will talk about two nebulizers from the world-famous Japanese corporation Omron.

Omron nebulizers have a universal nebulization and free a person from recognizing certain types of diseases of the respiratory zones, i.e. warn against purchasing extra inhalers that are not suitable for you. Nebulizers are based on the spraying of medication poured into the nebulizer chambers, which is broken up by a unique “bump” and sprayed into individual small particles into the middle and lower respiratory tract. Omron nebulizers allow you to effectively treat the entire respiratory system: runny nose, acute respiratory viral infections, acute respiratory infections, bronchial asthma.

Let's take a closer look at the differences between these seemingly identical nebulizers. The first and most important thing is, of course, weight . Omron C24 has a significantly light weight of 270 g, which makes it stand out in comparison with Omron C28 weighing 1900 g. Mobility is the main motto of C24. Now transporting the device does not cause headaches. Moreover, both nebulizers come with a bag for storage and transportation.

The light weight and compact dimensions of the C24 made it possible to reduce the noise level to 45 dB, compared to the C28 this is 15 dB less. This advantage allows you to use the nebulizer without disturbing your relatives at home at any time.

Also, the connecting hose in the Omron C24 inhaler is shorter and simpler than the hose of the Omron C28 inhaler. This does not affect the quality of the device, but makes it less mobile. For example, when using the C28, the inhaler can be placed away from the patient at a distance of up to 2 m. Below are the dimensions of the hoses of the two inhalers.

Connection hoses Omron C24 and Omron C28

The bag for storing the inhaler in the Omron C24 model is also more spacious, but at the same time all the components fit perfectly in both models

Omron C24 and Omron C28 inhaler bags

Among the advantages of the C28, I would like to note the presence in the package of a moisture-proof switch, which prevents liquid or medications from entering the nebulizer unit. The abundance of spare parts for the C28 makes it more versatile and ensures frequent and long-term use.

Such advantages as: the use of a wide range of medical solutions , excluding home-made oils and herbal decoctions; maximum aerosol intake during inhalation and minimal loss during exhalation; ease of use; the optimal movement of the air flow of the compressor for children, weakened and elderly people makes C24 and C28 similar to each other.

Nebulizer chambers of Omron C24 and Omron C28 inhalers

One of the significant differences between these inhalers is the continuous operation time. For C24 it is limited to 20 minutes, and for C28 there are no time limits.

The package contents of both devices are almost identical.

Equipment for Omron C24 and Omron C28 inhalers

So, who should I recommend which device? If you need a simple portable device on the road, you don’t get sick often and using a nebulizer takes a short time in your life - then your choice is Omron CompAir NE-C24-RU. But if you want to purchase a high-quality device for long-term use by the whole family, then the Omron CompAir NE-C28-E is right for you.

Comparative characteristics of inhalers (nebulizers)

Home » Useful articles » Comparative characteristics of inhalers (nebulizers)

Having analyzed some brands of nebulizers, we have compiled tables that present the comparative characteristics of inhalers. After studying these tables, you can get a comprehensive answer to the question: how to choose an inhaler ?

Omron brand. Inhaler type - compressor

Common features for all Omron compressor nebulizers: any drugs are used for inhalation, including hormones and antibiotics. Average particle size 3 microns, reservoir volume 2-7 ml, residual volume 0.7 ml, warranty - 3 years. Storage bag. Manufacturer – Japan, assembly – China.

Model pros Minuses
NE-C20
  • Compact, lightweight -190g
  • Reduced noise level 45 dB.
  • Intermittent operating mode (works for 20 minutes, rests for 40): does not overheat.
  • Air tube – 100 cm (short)
  • aerosol jet is weak
NE-C24
  • more powerful than the previous one,
  • Reduced noise level 46 dB
  • Light - 270 g.
  • There is a special virtual valve technology (VVT), thanks to which drug losses are eliminated.
  • Intermittent operating mode (works for 20 minutes, rests for 40): does not overheat.
  • Works only from the network.
  • Air tube – 100 cm.
NE-C24 Kids
  • Corresponds to the description of the NE-C24 model, only designed specifically for children.
  • In addition to adult and children's masks, the set includes a mask for infants and 2 toys.
  • Children's design
  • Intermittent operating mode (works for 20 minutes, rests for 40): does not overheat.
  • Works only from the network
  • Air tube – 100 cm.
NE-C28
  • The most popular!
  • the most powerful compared to previous models.
  • The long air tube is 207 cm, convenient for use by a bedridden patient.
  • Can work for a long time thanks to the built-in fan and cooling compressor.
  • VVT technology - loss of the drug during spraying is minimal.
  • Works only from the network.
  • Weight – 1.9 kg
  • Noisy 60 dB.
NE-C29
  • Same as described for NE-C28, but has storage compartment for camera and accessories.
  • Works only from the network.
  • Weight – 2.3 kg
  • Noisy 60 dB.
Elite NE-C-30
  • Powered by mains and batteries.
  • Not heavy - Weight 440 g
  • Possible boiling of parts.
  • VVT technology - loss of the drug during spraying is minimal.
  • Noisy 53 dB

Omron brand. Inhaler type – Mesh nebulizers (electronic mesh)

Model pros Minuses
MicroAir U22
  • Manufactured and assembled in Japan!
  • The lightest in the world - 97 g
  • Closed chamber type, so it can be used at any angle with any drugs
  • Silent - less than 20 dB.
  • The residual volume is only 0.1 ml (the most economical use of the drug!)
  • You can use small volumes of the drug - 0.5 ml
  • The medicine does not need to be diluted
  • 4 hours of continuous operation
  • switching particle size
  • 2 modes: automatic (continuous inhalation) and manual (intermittent)
  • Operates on mains power or batteries (included)
  • High price

A&D brand

General for A & D : Warranty – 5 years (except A&D UN-233), service life – 10 years. Most models include adult and child masks (UN-232 has only an adult mask), and a mouthpiece.

Manufacturer – Japan, assembly – China.

Model Type pros Minuses
A&D CN-231 Compressor
  • Overheat protection function.
  • switching particle size
  • Tank volume 5-13 ml
  • Powered by network
  • Noisy – 60 dB
  • Weight 1.5 kg
A&D CN-232 Compressor
  • Similar to the previous one, only made in an original design - “fun whale” - designed specifically for children
  • Weight 1.6 kg,
A&D UN-231 Ultrasonic
  • Compact, lightweight, weight 185 g
  • Low noise level (34 dB)
  • Automatically turns off after 10 minutes
  • Just 1 ml of medicine is enough
  • Works only from the network
  • The inhaler works ONLY with water and water-based medications.
  • Cannot be used with hormones or antibiotics
A&D UN-232 Ultrasonic
  • With heated aerosol.
  • The optimal steam temperature is 43 degrees.
  • Overheat protection - built-in timer for 5 minutes.
  • 2 aerosol spray modes.
  • works only from the network
  • Weight – 1.5 kg
  • Only one adult mask
  • Noise - 45 dB
  • Cannot be used with hormones or antibiotics.
A&D UN-233 MESH
  • Very light and compact – 98 g
  • Powered by mains and batteries
  • Works with any drugs in quantities from 0.5 to 8 ml
  • Can be used at any angle (convenient to use for bedridden patients)
  • Almost silent – ​​32 dB
  • Adult and child masks included
  • Automatic shutdown after 10 seconds. in the absence of medicine.
  • The price is significantly lower than similar models from other brands

Trademark Microlife (made in Switzerland)

Model View pros Minuses
NEB-10 Compressor
  • Three inhalation modes: for the treatment of diseases of the upper, middle and lower respiratory tract
  • You can use all medications intended for nebulizer therapy and even oil solutions (it’s better not to)
  • Valve drug delivery system for economical use of drugs
  • Works only from the network
  • Noise -53 dB
  • Weight – 2 kg
NEB-100 Compressor
  • Compact, lightweight - 1.2 kg
  • Increased volume of the medicinal chamber: allows for a long inhalation procedure
  • All medications intended for nebulizer therapy can be used
  • increased inhalation rate
  • Works only from the network
  • Noise - 56 dB.
NEB-50 Compressor
  • All medications intended for nebulizer therapy can be used
  • minimal loss of drug during exhalation
  • up to 30 min. continuous operation
  • synchronization with breathing
  • Valve drug delivery system for economical use of drugs
  • works only from the network
  • Weight - 1.8 kg
  • Noise - 53 dBA

Brand B.Well (UK)

for inhalers B. Well : warranty period 2 years. Free service – 10 years.

Model View pros Minuses
WN-117 Compressor
  • Includes masks for children and adults, mouthpiece
  • Automatically switches off when overheated
  • The operating mode is intermittent. 30 minutes on, 30 minutes off.
  • Noise 60 dB
  • Weight 1.3 kg
WN-119U Ultrasonic
  • Compact, lightweight (weight 228 g)
  • 2 spray speeds (you can choose a convenient mode)
  • Overheat protection function
  • Can be powered by car adapter (sold separately)
  • The set includes masks for children and adults, a mouthpiece (for inhalation through the mouth)
  • Do not use with hormones, antibiotics
WN-116U Ultrasonic
  • “Closed water tank” system – there is no need to dilute the medicine with water. 0% loss of drug thanks to unique technology.
  • You can adjust the strength of the air stream,
  • Automatically switches off after 3 minutes (you can add medicine if necessary).
  • Includes mask, mouthpiece, nose piece. Can be powered by battery, mains or car adapter.
  • Weight – 260 g
  • Max. amount of drug – 8 ml
  • Do not use with hormones, antibiotics
WN-114 MESH
  • Weight – 137 g
  • Silent,
  • Works with any drugs
  • The residual volume is minimal.
  • Powered by mains and batteries (100 minutes of continuous operation)
  • Automatically turns off after 20 minutes.
WN-114 child MESH
  • Everything is the same as the previous one, only a bright design with a giraffe.

Trademark MED 2000 (made in Italy, assembled in China)

Model View pros Minuses
Dog, Kitty, Penguin, etc. Compressor
  • 3 nozzle pistons included, which provide different particle sizes. The upper, middle and lower respiratory tract can be treated.
  • There is a mouthpiece, nasal cannulas, adult and children's masks.
  • Works 30 min. break
  • You can use water-based and oil-based (preferably not necessary)
  • Warranty – 5 years.
  • Noise 54 dB
  • Weight about 1.5 kg

How to choose an inhaler

Types of inhalers

Inhalation is a therapeutic procedure during which a drug enters the nasal or respiratory tract in the form of small particles.
The simplest inhalation is spending time over a saucepan of hot boiled potatoes. However, the process of inhaling potato vapors is miserably inferior to inhalations, which are carried out using modern inhalation systems.

Today there are four types of inhalers:

  • steam, or heat-moist;
  • ultrasonic;
  • compressor;
  • mesh inhalers.

The simplest devices among this family are steam (heat-moisture) inhalers. The remaining three types are quite complex inhalation systems, often referred to as “nebulizers”. This term comes from the Latin word nebula, which means cloud or fog.

Remember: if a doctor recommends buying a nebulizer, he means an ultrasonic, compressor or mesh inhaler, and not a steam one. All modern inhalers are designed for inhalation of the nasal cavity and respiratory tract and are equipped with a set of attachments for the nose and mouth.

Steam inhalers

The steam generated by steam inhalers enters the nasopharynx along with the current of inhaled air and helps to dilate the vessels of the mucous membrane. As a result, blood supply improves, and therefore metabolism in the mucous membranes of the nose and upper respiratory tract.

B.Well PRO-110

4.8/5

226 reviews

Buy Yandex Market

average price

RUB 1,974

Characteristics

  • attachments: adult mask, mouth attachment, children's mask, nose attachment
  • average particle size: 3.16 microns
  • spray rate: 0.4 ml/min
  • medicine container volume: 8 ml
  • continuous operation time: 30 min
  • power supply: mains

Second place in the TOP is taken by B.Well PRO-110. Provides fairly fast inhalation due to a spray rate of 0.4 ml/min. The “Basic” nebulizer creates an aerosol with particles ranging in size from 3 to 5 microns , but most particles are 3.16 microns, so the medicine penetrates into the lungs all the way to the alveoli.

The container for medicines is larger than that of AND CN-233 - 8 ml . Children and adults can use it. The kit includes a mouthpiece, a mask in two sizes, and a nosepiece that allows you to use the nebulizer when you have a runny nose. Works continuously for 30 minutes . It operates quietly – 54 dB.

Pros:

  • Design.
  • Excellent build quality, durable body.
  • Comfortable in using.
  • Spray speed is good.
  • All the necessary attachments and masks for the family.

Minuses:

  • There is a single case of malfunction and defect.

Price – 1,900 rubles . High-quality, reliable, has the capabilities of professional devices and complies with the European standard for nebulizers. Compared to AND CN-233, it has a lower noise level, faster operating speed and a larger drug capacity, but its residual chamber volume is smaller (1 ml). 97% of users praised the quality and reliability, as well as ease of use, especially considering the low price.

Reviews on Yandex.Market

Rating
( 1 rating, average 5 out of 5 )
Did you like the article? Share with friends:
For any suggestions regarding the site: [email protected]
Для любых предложений по сайту: [email protected]